Wednesday, June 4, 2008

Eco-town shortlist

Eco-town shortlist revealed

The Government has named 15 potential locations for further detailed consideration as eco-towns in England.

Communities and Local Government has stressed that none of the proposed new homes will be built on Green Belt land and that at least 30 per cent of the housing will be affordable.

Publication of the shortlisted locations has indicated that they make significant use of previously developed brownfield land including former MoD land, military depots, disused airfields and former collieries and industrial sites.

More than 40 proposals have not been taken forward. Ministers decided that some were undeliverable or not ambitious enough to meet the high environmental and affordability standards set by the Government.

Housing and planning minister Caroline Flint has announced that a panel of experts will be set up to help developers improve their proposals and ensure the final eco-towns incorporate the best and most innovative proposals for sustainable living.

She said: "We have a major shortfall of housing and with so many buyers struggling to find suitable homes, more affordable housing is a huge priority. To face up to the threat of climate change, we must also cut the carbon emissions from our housing. Eco-towns will help solve both of these challenges.

"Building in existing towns and cities alone simply cannot provide enough new homes. I understand this is an issue that can raise strong opinions, but everyone now has the opportunity to express their views before any decisions are made - because this is an issue that affects us all."

The minister added: "Some really innovative green ideas have been proposed - from free public transport for all residents to using the waste heat from nearby power stations to heat homes and businesses. But I am setting the bar high and challenging bidders to go further.

"I have already rejected more than 40 proposals and those promoting eco-town schemes cannot rest on their laurels. That is why I want a panel of experts challenging developers to meet the highest standards possible for sustainability, affordability and creativity."

Ministers will now consult widely on the shortlisted locations with a final shorlist due to be published later this year after which each potential eco-town will need to submit a planning application.

A total of 57 initial proposals were received from local authorities and developers across the country. The 15 shortlisted locations are:

  • Pennbury, Leicestershire: 12-15,000 homes on a development incorporating brownfield, greenfield and surplus public sector land four miles south east of Leicester.
  • Manby and Strubby, Lincolnshire: 5,000 homes put forward by East Lindsey District Council on two sites, with large elements of brownfield land including a former RAF base.
  • Curborough, Staffordshire: 5,000 homes on the brownfield site of the former Fradley airfield, ten miles from Burton.
  • Middle Quinton, Warwickshire: 6,000 homes on a former Royal Engineers depot which has a rail link to the Worcester-London rail line and is six miles south west of Stratford upon Avon.
  • Bordon-Whitehill, Hampshire: 5-8,000 homes on a site owned by the Ministry of Defence. A significant number of ex-MoD homes are already on the site, west of Whitehill-Bordon.
  • Weston Otmoor, Oxfordshire: 10-15,000 homes on a site adjoining the M40 and the Oxford-Bicester railway. Three miles south west of Bicester, the site includes a current airstrip.
  • Ford, West Sussex: 5,000 homes on a site which includes brownfield land and the former Ford airfield. Close to rail line linking London and the Sussex coast.
  • Imerys China Clay Community, Cornwall: Development of around 5,000 homes on former china clay workings, industrial land and disused mining pits no longer needed by owner Imerys. The site is close to St Austell.
  • Rossington, South Yorkshire: Up to 15,000 homes regenerating the former colliery village of Rossington, three miles south of Doncaster.
  • Coltishall, Norfolk: 5,000 homes on a former RAF airfield, eight miles north of Norwich.
  • Hanley Grange, Cambridgeshire: 8,000 homes on land adjacent to the A11.
  • Marston Vale and New Marston, Bedfordshire: up to 15,400 homes on a series of sites, including former industrial sites, along the east-west rail line to Stewartby and Millbrook.
  • Elsenham, Essex: a minimum of 5,000 homes north east of the existing Elsenham village. Close to M11 and the London to Cambridge rail line.
  • Rushcliffe, Nottinghamshire: An eco-town proposal was submitted for Kingston-on-Soar, to the south of Nottingham. In response to representations from Rushcliffe Borough Council, this site is not to be pursued. However, the Government is proposing to carry out a further review in partnership with the council to consider whether there is a suitable alternative location.
  • Leeds City Region, Yorkshire: a number of eco-town proposals were submitted for locations within the area of Leeds City Region partnership of 11 authorities, principally between Leeds and Selby. The Leeds City Region Partnership has indicated support in principle for an eco-town within the sub-region. The Partnership has proposed a further study to compare the best alternative locations across the area. The Government has agreed to support this approach, on the basis that it will allow a further announcement to be made shortly of one or more sites for consultation.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Would you help us out by putting a link to the official campaign against Weston Otmoor on you blog? It's http://www.westonfront.com

Many thanks.

Anonymous said...

http://www.antimetrix.org/
What has Privatising military training got do with eco towns?

You may not have heard of the campaign to oppose the governments bizarre plan to privatise military training and build a mega military academy at St Athan in Wales - this is the biggest PFI/PPP ever, with arms dealers Raytheon Serco!
M Hayle, chief exec Metrix 'Our aim is that by 2013 if you travelled anywhere in the world and talked about military training, people would say that St Athan was the only place to go. John Pilger "a British "School of the Americas" is to be built in Wales, where British soldiers will train killers from all corners of the American empire in the name of "global security"."

The financing of the DTR (defence training review) site has been rocked by the shaky economy. The Metrix led consortium had planned to fund the project through the sale of surplus MoD land but with the housing market hitting rock bottom, predicted revenues are now substantially less than first believed. Rising inflation has led to a ballooning of costs to £12bn. (1)

There was an article in the telegraph in June Government in line to make millions from selling Ministry of Defence land for eco-towns By Vikki Miller and Patrick Hennessy, Political Editor 29/06/2008 “The truth behind Gordon Brown's flagship eco-town policy can be disclosed, with the Government set to raise millions from the schemes while watering down their green credentials. The Sunday Telegraph can report that the Treasury stands to make about £275million through land sales, because six out of the 15 shortlisted sites are on property either sold or earmarked for sale by the Ministry of Defence (MoD). Critics claim the Government is forcing the unpopular eco-towns on the public to make more money from the land and say the process by which the final locations are to be selected is flawed, because ministers will have a vested interest in choosing the MoD sites.”

A similar story appeared in the Independent on the same day. Eco-towns could net Treasury £275m By Sadie Gray Sunday, 29 June 2008 (2) "Government plans for new eco-towns could make £275m fo the Treasury in land sales, as almost half the shortlisted sites are on MoD land marked for disposal. Five eco-towns are to be built by 2016 and a further five by 2020. Of 15 potential sites, six are on MoD land that is either for sale or has already been sold. Critics claim that ministers charged with deciding on the locations will have a vested interest in picking the MoD sites, according to The Sunday Telegraph. In the case of the former Royal Engineers depot at Long Marston, the Government stands to make up to £84m from a clawback agreement giving it 50 per cent of the land's increased value if chosen for an eco-town. MoD clawback clauses typically demand between 30 and 50 per cent. A spokesman for the Communities and Local Government Department said: "If surplus public-sector land is available in the right area, then it is right to consider development on such brownfield sites in preference to the green belt."

SOUTH EAST ENGLAND DEVELOPMENT AGENCY BOARD MEETING ON 19th JUNE 2008 ITEM 8 Eco Town Proposals in the South East
SOUTH EAST ENGLAND DEVELOPMENT AGENCY tells us that the Green Town Vision proposals to expand the town onto the MoD site (which predate the eco town initiative), have been developed over a number of years ...
(3) Whitehill / Bordon is a garrison town where the Ministry of Defence presence makes a large contribution to supporting the local economy and social fabric. The MoD have announced their departure as part of the Defence Training Review (estimated date 2012-2015, possibly phased). The town will be hugely sensitive to the withdrawal, which will exacerbate issues of economic activity rates, unemployment, housing mix and quality and social cohesion.
The Green Town Vision proposals to expand the town onto the MoD site (which predate the eco town initiative), have been developed over a number of years with full public consultation, and have strong community support. Up to 5500 homes and between 2800-5600 jobs are proposed.

Handy idea to use a bit of greenwash to try and sell some land that isn’t moving
But the government insist the eco towns and the proposed privatisation of military training will go ahead as planned. They didn’t factor in the credit crunch. Both projects are now doomed.

(1) http://www.antimetrix.org/2008/09/leaked-mod-memo-bad-news-for-st-athan.html
(2) http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/ecotowns-could-net-treasury-163275m-856667.html
(3) www.seeda.co.uk/About_SEEDA/Board_members/board_meetings/papers/June2008/Item8-EcoTownsBoardReport.doc

Fair trade shop said...

That's great list..I wonder that it's very hectic to prepare such list. I would say thanks for such stunning list.

yadhav said...

I actually enjoyed reading through this posting.Many thanks.



Property for Sale in Leicester